I tried 5 Evolution Fresh juices, and this is what I thought

by Amy Sowder, Jan 25, 2023

On a recent early afternoon, I stared down a lineup of five juices. Some were green. Others were orange.

I was about to taste them all, live on camera with other tasters during the Evolution Fresh Winter Wellness Virtual Tasting — just a few days before National Green Juice Day on Jan. 26, a holiday created by Evolution Fresh in 2016, according to National Day Calendar.

The primarily organic, cold-pressed, premium juices first came to my attention more than half a year ago.

On Aug. 1, Bolthouse Farms — the Bakersfield, Calif.-based carrot grower and maker of premium juices found in the retail produce aisle — finalized the acquisition of Evolution Fresh, which was a Starbucks juice brand.

Now Evolution Fresh juices are also available in supermarkets nationwide, where other fresh, refrigerated juices are housed next to the fresh produce, as well as Starbucks locations.

Related news: Bolthouse Farms closes deal to acquire Evolution Fresh from Starbucks

Cold-pressed is a pasteurization process using high pressure rather than the more common high-heat pasteurization.

“This process just helps protect the flavor and nutrients, and it really allows for those natural tastes and flavors from the produce itself to shine,” said May Zhu, a registered dietitian nutritionist and Evolution Fresh partner who helped lead the virtual presentation.

On that virtual tasting day, I faced these flavors, in order of least sweet to most sweet:

  • Organic Green Devotion.
  • Organic Sweet Apple Greens.
  • Organic Pure Orange Juice.
  • Tangerine Juice.
  • Organic Defense Up.
compostable, water-soluble packaging

As someone who avoids sugars (except in desserts and in fresh, whole fruits), I loved the Green Devotion drink the best because the only pressed fruit inside was lemon. And with celery, cucumber, spinach, romaine, kale and parsley, the drink needs that bright kick of citrus. The drink wasn’t bitter. It was actually quite tasty, containing only 8 grams of sugar, and none of it added.

On the other end of the spectrum is the Organic Defense Up drink filled with orange, apple, mango, pineapple and acerola. What is acerola, you may ask?

It’s an underutilized cherry hailing from Brazil, according to a 2018 Journal of Food Science Technology study, “Acerola, an untapped functional superfruit: A review on latest frontiers,” by Anand Prakash and Revathy Baskaran.

Acerola is one of the richest natural sources of ascorbic acid, with 1,500 to 4,500 milligrams, which is 50 to 100 times more than that of a lemon or orange, according to the study. The cherry also contains a plethora of phytonutrients, such as carotenoids phenolics, anthocyanins and flavonoids.

The fruit “holds promising agro-industrial and pharmaceutical applications,” the researchers concluded.

Well, those health benefits verified by sound research helps convince me that the drink’s “Defense Up” name is quite appropriate — and it makes swallowing 51 grams of sugar (none added!) more palatable. Although, I did spread it across two days, and with the second half of the drink, I mixed it with sparkling water. The drink is quite cloying, but that’s the way the whole fruit tastes anyway. Go figure.

“I can personally vouch for the fact that it's amazing. It's very versatile. It's amazing as a popsicle,” said Alice Nelen, senior director of marketing at Evolution Fresh. “So, it makes for a really sweet and healthy treat both during the cold and flu season but also in the summer. My kids absolutely love it.”

The straight-up orange juice tastes much fresher and more like drinking the juice of an orange you just sliced than any OJ cartons found in the refrigerated dairy aisle of the grocery store. It possibly tasted even better than the fresh-squeezed orange juice we make at home. Evolution Fresh's oranges are mostly the valencia variety and could’ve been fresher than mine!

“Probably the most common reaction we get when people taste our orange juice for the first time is like ‘Wow, this actually tastes like an orange,’ which is really silly feedback for orange juice. But it is a difference for us of tasting fresh-picked versus what people are used to, which would be heat-pasteurized,” said Sam Lindsey, senior manager of research and development at Evolution Fresh.

Orange juice is the most popular juice for consumers, and 50% of it is consumed in the morning, Nelen said.

zoom juice tasting event

The other green drink is probably much more of a crowd-pleaser, as it has apple and pineapple to sweeten the deal. Still, there’s cucumber, celery, spinach and romaine in there. The tangerine juice was a delight as well. The flavor is a little different and welcome.

The juices can be used as an ingredient in other recipes as well, such as the Green Devotion juice in this Creamy Green Goddess Dressing for salads, and the Orange Cleansicle using the orange juice. That orange smoothie recipe is inspired by model Bella Hadid’s smoothie, the Kinsicle, in partnership with SoCal-based Erewhon Market.

Evolution Fresh is tapping into the retail market for premium juices, taking action based on consumer research that shows the desire for foods with functional benefits in winter but also year-round.

“We really, really love encouraging getting nutrients through food first versus supplements. And ideally, we get a fruit or vegetables in every meal. But sometimes with schedules, it's just not feasible,” Zhu said. “And there's just really high interest right now in functional foods and ingredients that supports immunity.”

Become a Member Today